Select a theme:   Light Mode  |  Dark Mode
November 18, 2026

Are holiday deals really deals? A Binghamton marketing expert explains how retailers use psychology to drive sales

Assistant Professor of Marketing Jintao Zhang breaks down Black Friday discounts and offers tips for smarter holiday shopping

Image Credit: StockPhotoPro.

The holiday shopping season is here, and stores and websites are suddenly flush with signs and buttons calling out reduced prices, “save up to 50% off” deals, and more. What is driving all of these promotions, and what does this mean for busy consumers trying to get the most bang for their buck? 

Jintao Zhang, assistant professor of marketing at Binghamton University, studies how consumers respond to pricing information and digital marketing cues. His research examines how small changes in pricing and messaging can affect consumer decision-making.

We caught up with him to break down the psychology behind in-person and online promotions and how to shop smarter this holiday season. 

Let’s cut to the chase. Are holiday discounts real savings, or are retailers just playing games with prices?

I believe there are actual deals offered, but we know that retailers often raise prices by 10% to 20% a month or two ahead of holiday sales, and then enhance the discount. 

Also, consumers don’t remember past prices. It depends on how often you shop for those kinds of products and how familiar people are with them. Consumers focus only on the nominal value of a discount — that it’s 50% off or $40 off — and not on the difference between the original price and the sale price. 

So should shoppers pay closer attention to prices before the holidays?

Yes. I think they should start looking at products one to two months before Black Friday sales. That way, they can document the regular price and catch the increase in price and not fall into the retailers’ trap.

What makes holiday shopping unique from the rest of the year?

Holiday shopping has become a tradition. Retailers have been promoting it for so many years, and I believe people's mindsets have changed based on their shopping experiences. They have this expectation that big discounts always come from holiday promotions, so that shifts their curiosity toward them. If they are craving a deeper discount, they're more likely to purchase during the holidays than during regular promotions throughout the year.

What are some strategies shoppers should watch for this holiday season?

Part of the research I am working on now is what’s called tensile pricing. “Save up to $20. Save up to 40% on the whole site.” That kind of pricing is pretty common. We’re going to see that a lot in Black Friday sales. 

We recently found that presenting this pricing with a large variety of products works well for retailers. However, when retailers put just one product type next to that kind of pricing, it can hurt customer loyalty. We know that retailers are trying to save web space and increase efficiency. So they might put one type of product with an ad saying it will provide up to 40% off — and it could even be different colors or different types of one product. But people are less likely to trust this kind of advertisement, which will make them less likely to revisit the website again in the future. 

Holiday promotions often show an original price crossed out next to a newer, lower price. Does that presentation affect whether shoppers think they're getting a good deal?

One of my recent studies looked at this strikethrough pricing. We found that if retailers present a price like this, people are less likely to purchase the product because it makes it difficult to process the discount between the original price and the sale price. In our minds, we always want to know what kind of return we're going to get from a deal, right? Simply adding a strikethrough line on the original price will reduce the ease of that process.

What about buy-one-get-one-free promotions? Are those effective?

Not necessarily. In our research, we found that a straightforward price offer can be more effective than a buy-one-get-one-free promotion, even when the savings are identical. For example, if three bottles of juice normally cost $1.50 each, a promotion offering three for $3 performs better than advertising it as buy two, get one free. It's easier for consumers to process.

Retailers frequently use red prices and bright sale signs during the holiday shopping season. Does highlighting a price in red actually make a deal seem better?

In our research, we found that if there is a red price among other prices, people will stop looking at all the other deals and only focus on that one deal. That will actually hurt the business because red is a “stop sign” in people’s minds. They will not look at other deals in the store, and overall they'll perceive the store as not offering any discounts.

Is there a major difference in online versus in-person shopping in how consumers make purchasing decisions?

Since COVID, our behavior has shifted a lot. People are now more into online shopping compared to in-person shopping. The difference is that online, you can’t touch the product; in person, you can. Also, the environment is different, and people make different decisions based on how crowded it is. If you're shopping in a crowded environment, your perception of quality will dip. People are more likely to pay a higher price for a product because they think it is high quality. I think it's because when they're in a crowded environment, they have fewer mental resources to think about anything.

What's one thing consumers can do to make better purchasing decisions when they're bombarded with holiday promotions? 

I think they should think twice before making a purchase. We are surrounded by all of these discounts. We just feel like we are going to get a good deal. But at the end of the day, we are falling into the retailers' trap. So we need to calm down before making a real purchase. 

There is one thing that consumers can do to actually take advantage of retailers. If they want to purchase something online, they can put it into the shopping cart without checking out. One or two days later, they will maybe receive a coupon. In that way, they will get a better deal.

Posted in: In the World, SOM